Mainstream endocrinologists seem to be moving grudgingly toward acceptance of combination T4 plus T3 therapy for hypothyroidism. A great example of the mixed feelings harbored by endocrinologists in this regard is the title of a recent editorial, “ Combo (treatment) a Last Resort for Hypothyroidism” . Although the author, Dr. Bruce Jancin of the University of Colorado, recognized the value of combination T4 plus T3 therapy, he did so with the least possible enthusiasm. In his article the doctor acknowledged the weakness of scientific studies showing negative results with combination therapy and pointed out the findings of the Watts Study which provides a genetic rationale for why some people need to have T3 added to T4 to return to proper thyroid hormone balance. Continue reading
Treatment of hypothyroidism (low thyroid function) is accomplished by administering thyroid hormone by mouth in sufficient amounts to restore levels back to normal. At first glance this might seem like a simple goal to achieve. The truth is hormone replacement therapy is complex because there exists two very different thyroid hormones and because levels of thyroid hormone in the blood do not always reflect the amount of thyroid hormone within the cells where the hormone exerts its effects. In Part One of this blog I began to discuss how genetic differences among individuals could explain why some people need a complex mix of thyroid hormones to adequately treat hypothyroidism. In Part 2, I want to explain the nature of the differences between individuals and how it determines what sort of thyroid hormone therapy may be needed.
In May 2009 a group of researchers (Panicker, V. et al) in the UK published the WATTS study, the largest and most comprehensive study to date, of hypothyroid patients treated with combination t4 and t3. The goal of the study was to discover whether genetic differences in the population of hypothyroid patients accounts for some individuals needing t3 in addition to traditional t4 therapy. The researchers looked at 697 hypothyroid individuals and analyzed their DNA for differences in the portions controlling crucial enzymes which process thyroid hormones known as deiodinases. These enzymes are found widely distributed in the body including the thyroid, brain, muscle, liver, kidney and pituitary gland. As explained above, deiodinases convert t4 to the much stronger form of thyroid hormone, t3. At the same time the researchers measured patients’ mood and sense of well being on t4 alone and when t3 was added to the therapy.
Key findings of the WATTS study are that there is a substantial difference among individuals in the genes that make the deiodinases. In other words, due to genetic differences (mutations), there are differences in the way individuals make t3 out of t4. In a group of people, mutations in the genes that make a particular protein (in this case, the deiodinase), are called polymorphisms. The researchers discovered that a certain mutation in the deiodinase gene is associated with a poor sense of well being on t4 only therapy, and in the presence of this mutation a significantly better response to adding t3 can be found compared to those without this mutation. Of the group of hypothyroid patients studied in the UK about 16% possessed the faulty deiodinase gene. In other groups in other countries the percentage of people with this mutation could be higher or lower.
The traditional treatment of hypothyroidism is to administer t4 (Synthroid, Levothyroxine, Levoxyl etc.). It is the conventional wisdom that inactive t4 is converted in the body to the active thyroid hormone t3 by “peripheral conversion” in sufficient amounts to restore normal thyroid balance. The recent breakthrough discoveries described in the WATTS study reveal for the first time that individuals differ in how their bodies process (metabolize) thyroid hormone. While some may convert enough t4 to t3 in the cells of the body to restore normal function, due to genetic differences some individuals will not be able to make enough t3 leaving them with persistent hypothyroid symptoms. Since the problem is a deficiency of t3 within the cells of the body, measuring thyroid hormone levels in the blood cannot adequately reveal the problem. T4 replacement treatment alone can result in thyroid levels that appear normal on blood tests so doctors conclude that persistent hypothyroid symptoms are not related to the hormone therapy.
Based on my personal experience and the documented experience of many of the members of Metabolism.com it is clear that endocrinologists and other physicians are often reluctant to consider combination therapy for hypothyroidism, either by using Armour thyroid or adding t3 (Cytomel, liothyronine) to t4 only therapy. With this new research in hand, hypothyroid individuals and their advocates can finally state with confidence that: Yes! There is a firm scientific foundation for combination t4/t3 therapy and; No! We are not just chronic complainers or kooks. If I had hypothyroidism and was going to request a change in my thyroid treatment I would say something like, “Due to polymorphism of the deiodinase gene I probably possess a defective D2 deiodinase and therefore my peripheral conversion of t4 to t3 is impaired. I need t3 added to t4 to compensate for reduced intracellular t3 levels which cannot be detected on blood tests. Without t3 I continue to suffer with cellular hypothyroidism which is the likely cause of my persistent symptoms.”
If you try this approach and your doctor looks bewildered hand them a copy of the study by Panicker et al in the Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism, 2009, 94(5): 1623-1629.
Gary Pepper, M.D.
Notice: This article is for informational purposes only and does not substitute for the advice or treatment of your own physician. The disclaimer for all blogs at metabolism.com, applies.